A Brooklyn man says his Ford Flex was held hostage by an auto repair shop — and racked up more than $2,000 in parking fines. Here’s how he’s ‘going to fight’ to get it back

'I’m going to fight for that car'

As the days turned into months following his accident, Denory couldn’t get a clear answer on when his vehicle would be fixed. And then the fines started showing up in the mail.

By August, 2024, a judge ruled that State to State Automotive was responsible for paying the parking tickets, but the shop still hasn’t paid the fines. Denory and McNicholas went to State to State's shop around this time to ask about the SUV.

"Where's this guy's car?" McNicholas asked a man at the shop, to which the man replied, “We don't have a Ford Flex here.”

In October, 2024, Denory finally tracked down his vehicle, which was at a parking lot near the auto shop. But when he arrived to take it back, Denory was met with more bad news — the SUV wouldn’t start, had flat tires and a truck was blocking the exit to the lot.

When he demanded his vehicle back, Denory said an unidentified worker brought up “storage fees.”

“I’m not paying no storage. I don’t care what you’re saying,” Denory said. “Then you’re not getting the car back,” the man replied.

Later, Denory and McNicholas revisited the lot and found someone had moved his vehicle closer to the exit. With help from his insurance company, which sent someone to jumpstart the vehicle and pump up the tires, Denory was able to drive his SUV home for the first time in 20 months. But the fight apparently isn’t over.

Denory still doesn't know if his vehicle was properly fixed despite Geico Insurance's claim that the shop cashed the $6,000 check to cover the repair costs. He is now working with the sheriff’s office to try to get the funds from the shop for the unpaid parking tickets.

The Department of Motor Vehicles is also investigating State to State Automotive, though they declined to offer details.

Kiss your credit card debt goodbye

Millions of Americans are struggling to crawl out of debt in the face of record-high interest rates. A personal loan offers lower interest rates and fixed payments, making it a smart choice to consolidate high-interest credit card debt. It helps save money, simplifies payments, and accelerates debt payoff. Credible is a free online service that shows you the best lending options to pay off your credit card debt fast — and save a ton in interest.

Explore better rates

What to do when you're in Denory's shoes

Denory finally has his Ford Flex back, but other customers of the same auto shop say their vehicles are also being held hostage. No one wants to experience this kind of frustration, so what can you do to avoid finding yourself in a similar situation?

You can start by checking out the auto repair shop’s online reviews. After that, extend your research to the Better Business Bureau, where you can see if the shop has any negative complaints. If anything in your research gives you pause, find another auto shop in your area and conduct your research over again.

When you land on an auto shop that's earned your confidence, request a written estimate that includes the costs, as well as a projected completion date before agreeing to the repairs. This can help you hold the shop accountable if things go wrong.

These steps can help you avoid Denory’s fate, but sometimes all the research in the world isn’t enough to prevent you from doing business with an unscrupulous company.

If you ever happen to find yourself in a similar situation to Denory’s, you can always file a complaint with the BBB or another government agency, such as the Division of Consumer Protection, the AG's office or your state's version of the Department of Motor Vehicles.

You can also take legal action. In extreme cases like Denory's, you may need to get legal assistance, and if hiring a lawyer is too expensive, you can always take the issue to small claims court.